Live Help
Live Help

Homebuilder has lodged a complaint versus Water District alleging water provided by the district causes leaks within pipes.

Santa Ana, CA: Two neighborhood developers have filed grievances with Orange County Superior Court declaring the water made available from two South County water districts is in fact corroding water pipe, causing leaking which need tens of thousands of dollars for copper repiping procedures and installations.

Shapell Industries submitted their complaint Nov 2, claiming normal water brought to you by Moulton Niguel Water District to Shapell properties in at least two Laguna Niguel communities; San Joaquin Hills as well as Hillcrest were treated with chloramine, a harsh disinfectant which Shapell suggested is known to cause pinhole leaks in the pipes of homeowners throughout the area.

The claim states Shapell “should be required to repair and remove and redo plumbing in nearly 600 condos” in those areas. The issue wouldn’t state the actual number of family homes that in some way have leaking. The construtor is attempting to get above $4 million in compensation, stating defective products, negligence, private nuisance and infraction of service.

MNWD offers service to 45,000 condos and companies in Laguna Niguel, Aliso Viejo, Laguna Hills and areas of Mission Viejo and San Juan Capistrano.

“The only clients filing a complaint associated with a lot of these galvanized pipe leaks live in residences constructed by Shapell within these pair of locales,” MNWD general manager Bob Gumerman said in a statement. “If water is to blame, the condition would definitely be widespread.”

Gumerman emphasized the district’s water matches or is much greater than federal and state water-quality guidelines and it is safe for bathing and additional usages. He stated Shapell has not produced documents about how MNWD’s water supply has caused pinhole pipe leaks in people’s homes. Many calls to the lawyers representing Shapell weren’t returned.

Gumerman pointed out Moulton Niguel gets its water from the Metropolitan Water District of Southern California, who imports it out of the Colorado River along with the State Water Project, a system of recollection facilities, tanks and lakes. As reported by its website, MWD works with chloramine, a mix of chlorine and ammonia, within the water treatment operation to eradicate organisms in water.

MWD also provisions water for the Santa Margarita Water District, which serves the rest of Mission Viejo coupled with Rancho Santa Margarita, Coto de Caza, Ladera Ranch together with the Talega neighborhood in San Clemente. MWD and SMWD were called as defendants in a complaint lodged Feb. 9 by Lennar Homes concerning pinhole pipe leaks in aged pipes within the Verano location of Talega.

Lennar’s claim claims leaks in galvanized pipes in 55 Verano homes “are a primary and/or additional reaction to corrosive, extreme and/or poorly treated water” supplied by the districts. Lennar demands the districts to be held responsible for the leaking along with any expenses, harms or settlements incurred by Lennar brought on by the leaks.

Newmeyer & Dillion attorney Carol Zaist, which is counseling Lennar, said the builder does not comment on pending litigation.

Newmeyer & Dillion additionally represents home builder Standard Pacific, which lodged a complaint delivered to the district in March noted 70 residences in Ladera Ranch and Talega where residence owners have complained of pinhole leaking in piping and pertinent property damage. The complaint was first declined by SMWD officials, though recently available research may overturn this initial decision.

SMWD speaker Michele Miller thought the district isn’t going to change or alter the water made available from MWD, in addition mentioning SMWD water meets or is higher than national water quality conditions. Concerning the results of water supply treatment methods, “the district believes that there isn’t any additional info to show this region’s water is causing a corrosive relation to galvanized plumbing.”

Marc Edwards is known as a Virginia Tech city and ecological engineering educator and a nationwide established specialist on pipe corrosion. A component of his attempts are to analyze what causes pipe failures and the way to avert them. He said that a number of cases are emerging in California in which he can possibly expect to become hired as the expert witness.

“We’ve produced surely more than a million dollars of basic research throughout the last seven years,” Edwards acknowledged. “We recognized that water chemistry and harsh water are major contributing factors of pinhole water leaks.

“We know that other elements are sometimes involved, including severe velocity in water lines and inadequate installation methods, therefore each individual case uses relatively considerable forensic analysis to attempt to recognize the possible root cause and treatment plans,” he added.

Edwards said similar standards implemented to make water safer may well be triggering pinhole pipe leaks. While it’s true disinfectants are essential, an excessive amount in some waters could be corrosive. He explained reports on chloramine shows it on its own doesn’t necessarily facilitate corrosion in water pipes, but “it may be possible, even probable, that chloramine plus other causes within the water can be remarkably corrosive.”

Despite the fact that the Water District might have great intentions, changes to satisfy regulations can be having unintended consequences, Edwards acknowledged.

“There’s definitely a good deal that we know,” he explained. “Now we have unambiguously recognized that this type of water may be a cause; not the sole cause, but a cause. There is certainly quite a lot many of us still don’t realize.”